Meeting Minutes Chat

General Assembly member representation

dgage@iaob.org · 2026-09-09 03:20 PM EDT

← Back
User 2026-09-09 03:21 PM EDT
General Assembly member representation
Assistant 2026-09-09 03:21 PM EDT
# General Assembly member representation The governing provisions are in **`01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Articles_of_Association_-_EN.txt`** (Articles 6.1(d), 9.1–9.5, 11.6–11.8, 12.1–12.2 and 7.3(b)). A French version of the same Articles is in the corpus as `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Articles_of_Association_-_FR.txt`, and the same text appears within `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Deed.txt` (Arts. 9.1–9.5 there). **Note on which language governs.** Article 25 (EN version) states: *"The Articles of Association are drafted in French and English, but only the French version represents the official text of the Articles of Association."* So the French wording is the official text; the English quotations below are from the English version in the corpus. ## 1. Who represents a Member (Art. 9.1 with Art. 6.1(d)) > "9.1 The General Assembly is formed by the Members of the Association. Each Member shall be represented by its representative designated in accordance with Article 6.1(d)." Article 6.1(d) requires each Member that is a legal entity to: > "designate an individual as its representative and another individual as alternate, to vote on behalf of such Member, it being understood that a Member may replace its representative or its alternate with immediate effect at any given time" So the standing arrangement is: one designated representative plus one alternate, replaceable at any time with immediate effect. ## 2. Proxy / delegation to another Member (Art. 9.2) > "9.2 Each Member may appoint on a case-by-case basis a person other than such Member's designated representative or alternate designated representative as its representative (proxy) to participate in a meeting of the General Assembly. Such appointment requires a signed delegation which may be transmitted to the Board via electronic communication. Delegations may only be granted to designated representatives or alternate representatives of another Member, and each Member may only receive one delegation per meeting of the General Assembly. The recipient of the delegation will be allowed to deliver different votes for the Member that he or she represents and for the Member which delivered delegation to her or him." Key limits: case-by-case only; signed delegation required; the proxy must be the designated or alternate representative **of another Member**; a maximum of **one delegation received per Member per meeting**; and split voting is expressly permitted. Article 11.8 sets out the transmission formality: > "11.8 Any Member may, by ordinary mail or any written electronic means of communication, including e-mail (a copy of which will be sent by similar means to the President of the Board), grant a delegation to another Member as set out in Article 9.2." ## 3. Voting weight (Art. 9.3) > "9.3 Each Member shall have one (1) vote, except for the cases explicitly foreseen in the present Articles of Association." ## 4. Effect of representation on quorum and majority (Art. 12.1–12.2) > "12.1 The General Assembly shall be quorate for vote if at least 75% of all Members with voting rights are present **or represented**." > "12.2 The General Assembly decides by 75% majority of votes cast by the Members with voting rights present **or represented** …" Article 22.1–22.4 uses the same "present or represented" formula for amendments to the Articles (and Art. 24.1 applies those conditions to dissolution). Remote participation counts as presence: Article 11.7 provides that Members participating by the Association's electronic means "are deemed to be present at the place where the meeting is held for the purpose of calculating presence and majority requirements." Article 11.6 adds that "Any Member present or represented at a meeting shall, unless such Member formally objects, be deemed to have been validly convened." One point to flag: Article 7.3(d) provides that exclusion "will require a vote of 75% of the **Members present**" — the word "represented" is not used there, unlike Articles 12.1–12.2 and 22. Whether that was deliberate is not explained anywhere I read, and I am not resolving it. ## 5. Consequence of non-participation (Art. 7.3(b)) > "If a Member has failed to directly participate through its designated representative or alternate in the General Assembly in 12 consecutive months and has not participated via delegation to another Member as per Article 9.2 either, such Member's voting right in the General Assembly will be (automatically and without further notice) suspended and will only be reinstated (automatically and without further notice) once such Member has participated in three successive meetings of the General Assembly." A registered warning letter then follows, and failure to resume participation within six months "will be considered to be a serious cause" for exclusion under Art. 7.3(a)(v). ## 6. Non-Member attendance (Art. 9.5) Third parties, "in particular representatives of distribution partners," may be invited by the Board as **guests without any voting right**, must sign confidentiality and compliance undertakings before admission, and "The Board must exclude any person so invited from all or individual agenda items if three or more Members so request." ## 7. Documents sent to representatives (Art. 11.4) Presentation material requiring a decision goes "to the designated representatives and the alternate designated representatives of all Member fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the meeting at the latest," and non-decision material seven (7) calendar days prior. --- **What I did not find.** The Internal Regulations at `02firstboardmeeting__IATF_AISBL_-_05_Minutes_of_First_Board_Meeting_-_Annex_5_Internal_Regulations.txt` deal only with **Committee** representation (Sections 4.1–4.4: one representative and one alternate per IATF member per Committee, with the alternate stepping in on declaration of unavailability). They contain no separate rules on representation at the General Assembly itself. Note that one of the 15 pages of that annex is a scanned image with no machine-readable text, so I cannot confirm what is on it. Also note that several related documents are scans with no readable text — the Minutes of the First General Assembly (`03firstgeneralassembly__...01_Minutes_of_First_General_Assembly.txt`, all 12 pages), the Delegation Letters, and the Notarial Declaration on Director Appointments. If your question concerns how representation was actually exercised or recorded at the first General Assembly, or the content of the delegation letters, that content is genuinely absent from the corpus rather than something I overlooked. This is a summary of the documents, not legal advice.
User 2026-09-09 03:29 PM EDT
how to disqualify a member representative
Assistant 2026-09-09 03:29 PM EDT
# Disqualifying a member representative **The short answer: for a Member's designated representative in the General Assembly, no disqualification mechanism exists in the documents I searched.** The power to remove or replace such a person sits exclusively with the appointing Member. The Association's levers operate against the *Member*, not against the individual. Committee seats are different, and I set those out below. ## 1. GA representatives: replacement is the Member's right alone `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Articles_of_Association_-_EN.txt`, Article 6.1(d) — each Member which is a legal entity shall: > "designate an individual as its representative and another individual as alternate, to vote on behalf of such Member, it being understood that **a Member may replace its representative or its alternate with immediate effect at any given time**" The French official text (`...-_FR.txt`, Art. 6.1(d)) is to the same effect: *"étant entendu qu'un Membre peut remplacer son représentant ou son suppléant avec effet immédiat à tout moment"*. Note Article 25: only the French version is the official text. Article 9.1 simply provides that "Each Member shall be represented by its representative designated in accordance with Article 6.1(d)." Nothing in Articles 9, 11, 12 or 18 confers on the Board or the General Assembly any power to reject, disqualify, suspend or unseat a person whom a Member has designated. Article 14.4 gives the General Assembly an express removal power over **Board** members ("Any Member of the Board may be removed by decision of the General Assembly by a 75% majority…"); the absence of any equivalent for Member representatives is conspicuous, and I am not going to read one in. ## 2. What the Association *can* do **(a) Against the Member (Art. 7.3).** If the concern is conduct, the route is exclusion of the Member, not disqualification of its representative. Article 7.3(a) lists the grounds — breach of Membership obligations under Article 6 (which include, at 6.1(e), compliance with "the compliance guidelines established by the General Assembly"), jeopardising the interests of the Association, or "any other serious cause". Procedure under Art. 7.3(c)–(d): initiated by the General Assembly or the Board; registered letter to the Member setting out the facts at least 60 days before the proposed exclusion date; an opportunity to remedy and to defend its position at the meeting; "Exclusion will require a vote of 75% of the Members present, and Article 12.4 shall not apply; the Member to be excluded shall not be entitled to vote." All rights of the Member are suspended from receipt of the Board's letter until the vote. **(b) Against non-participation (Art. 7.3(b)).** Failure to participate through the designated representative or alternate, or by delegation under Art. 9.2, for 12 consecutive months triggers automatic suspension of the Member's voting right, a registered warning letter, and — if participation is not resumed within six months — a "serious cause" for exclusion. **(c) Against guests only (Art. 9.5).** There *is* an express exclusion power, but it reaches only invited third parties: "The Board must exclude any person so invited from all or individual agenda items if three or more Members so request." Invited third parties must also sign "appropriate confidentiality and compliance undertakings" before admission. This does not apply to Member representatives. **(d) Qualification requirements — committees only (Art. 18.3).** The General Assembly "may decide to limit the number of persons admitted to each Committee… the General Assembly may also decide to request appropriate qualification for representatives to any Committee." This is a committee-level power; there is no parallel qualification power over GA representatives. ## 3. Committee seats: here removal powers do exist From `02firstboardmeeting__IATF_AISBL_-_05_Minutes_of_First_Board_Meeting_-_Annex_5_Internal_Regulations.txt`: - **Remuneration and Finance Committee (12.2) and Complaints Committee (13.2):** members are "personally elected as committee members by the General Assembly… **The General Assembly may at any time revoke the appointment of a committee member.** If a committee member vacates their position as committee member, a by-election shall be held." This is the only true disqualification power over an individual Member representative that I found. - **Global Oversight Committee (10.2):** "Each Oversight Office may revoke or replace its representatives at any time" — again, the appointing body's own right. Section 10.4 allows the Board to suspend an Oversight Office's *participation rights* for non-payment of fees. - **Supplier Committee (11.2.3):** contemplates a member who "ceases to be an Eligible Member, resigns or is **removed for cause**", to be replaced by an alternate appointed by the proposing association. The Regulations do not specify who decides "for cause" or by what procedure — that is a gap. - **Temporary stand-in (4.4):** on declaration by the representative or by the appointing member that the representative is unable to act, the alternate exercises the rights "until confirmation by the appointing member that the representative has resumed his or her duties." This is an unavailability mechanism, not a disqualification. - **Conflicts (Section 8):** Article 14.3 of the Articles applies *mutatis mutandis* to Committee members. The remedy there is disclosure and recusal, not removal. Section 12.4 likewise requires recusal, not disqualification, on own-remuneration decisions. ## 4. Points I cannot resolve - Whether a Member could be compelled to replace an individual representative — e.g. by treating that individual's conduct as a breach of Art. 6.1 attributable to the Member — is not addressed anywhere I read. That is a legal question on the documents, and I am not resolving it. - The Supplier Committee "removed for cause" trigger in 11.2.3 has no stated procedure. - One of the 15 pages of the Internal Regulations is a scanned image with no machine-readable text, so I cannot confirm what is on it. **What I searched for and did not find:** I ran searches across the corpus for *disqualif\**, *revoke/revocation*, *removal*, *"replace its representative"*, *"designated representative"*, *"alternate representative"*, *"exclude any person"* and *conflict of interest*. The only hits on revocation/removal of individuals are the Board-removal provisions (Arts. 10.1(d), 12.3(a), 14.4, 15.2), the committee provisions quoted above, and revocation language in the certification-scheme rules and trademark documents, which concern auditor approvals and trademark proceedings — not GA representatives. No document in the corpus sets out a procedure for disqualifying a Member's General Assembly representative. Also note that several potentially relevant documents are scans with no readable text — the Minutes of the First General Assembly (all 12 pages), the Delegation Letters, the Initial Committee Appointments, the Minutes of the First Board Meeting, and the Notarial Declaration on Director Appointments. If a disqualification practice was recorded there, that content is genuinely absent from the corpus rather than something I overlooked. This is a summary of the documents, not legal advice.
User 2026-09-09 03:31 PM EDT
who presides over the General Assembly?
Assistant 2026-09-09 03:31 PM EDT
# Who presides over the General Assembly **The President of the Board chairs GA meetings**, with the Vice President stepping in when the President is absent — but the Board can unanimously decide otherwise. ## The governing provision From `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Articles_of_Association_-_EN.txt`, Article 9.4: > "9.4 The President of the Board (or in his or her absence, the Vice President of the Board) chairs the meetings of the General Assembly, unless the Board unanimously decides otherwise." The official French text (Art. 25: "only the French version represents the official text") reads, in `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Articles_of_Association_-_FR.txt`: > "9.4 Le Président du Conseil (ou, en son absence, le Vice-Président du Conseil) préside les réunions de l'Assemblée Générale, sauf si le Conseil en décide autrement à l'unanimité." The same Article 9.4 appears within `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Deed.txt`. ## Corroborating provisions in the same Articles - **Art. 15.4(b)** — among the President of the Board's listed functions: *"chairs the meetings of the General Assembly and Board"*. Art. 15.4 also gives the President the roles of preparing and adopting the agenda (a), signing the minutes of the GA after approval by the GA and of the Board (c), and acting *"as a mediator when diverging opinions or conflicts emerge within the Association"* (d). - **Art. 15.1** — the general substitution rule: *"The President of the Board in his or her absence shall be represented in all his or her functions attributed to her or him by the present Articles of Association by the Vice President of the Board, and the latter by the third Board member (if appointed)."* So on a plain reading, if both President and Vice President are absent, the chair falls to the third Board member — where one has been appointed (Art. 14.2 permits, but does not require, a third member). - **Art. 13.1** — *"The President of the Board will have written minutes of all meetings of the General Assembly drawn up and have them kept by the Association."* - **Art. 14.2** — the President and Vice President are each *"appointed as such by the General Assembly"*; **Art. 15.2** governs replacement on incapacity, resignation, death or removal; **Art. 15.3** allows Internal Regulations to set eligibility criteria and *"other requirements and roles to be fulfilled by the President of the Board."* ## Two qualifications worth flagging **1. The "unless the Board unanimously decides otherwise" carve-out.** Article 9.4 lets the Board displace the default chair by unanimous decision. The Articles do not say who may be appointed instead, whether the decision is meeting-specific or standing, or whether the chosen chair must be a Board member or a Member representative. That is a genuine gap in the text, and I am not filling it. **2. Conflicts of interest (Art. 14.3).** Where a potential or perceived conflict involves the President or Vice President, that person must inform the GA and *"refrain from participating in, influencing, or receiving information about any deliberations or decisions of the Board, the Remuneration and Finance Committee, or any other body of the Association relating to the matter concerned."* Article 14.3 then provides: *"The General Assembly may, for the exercise of the concerned function from which the President or the Vice President concerned is recused, elect a special representative which will perform such function instead."* Whether "such function" extends to chairing the GA for the conflicted agenda item is not spelled out; the wording is broad enough to be read that way, but the Articles do not say so expressly. ## Duties attaching to whoever chairs The competition-compliance rules impose substantive obligations on the chair of any Association meeting. From `complianceguidelines__17_02_26_2.1_Guidelines_Set_1_Draft_8__Clean.txt`, section 1.14 (materially identical text appears in `02firstboardmeeting__IATF_AISBL_-_04_Minutes_of_First_Board_Meeting_-_Annex_4_Competition_Law_Guidelines.txt`): > "The chair ensures that the meeting is conducted in accordance with due and proper procedure. At the beginning of each meeting, the chair instructs those attending on compliance with competition law and verbalizes or displays section 3 of these Guidelines." Also: at least one member of Association staff should be present "either as chair or as assistance to the chair"; the chair holds a formal vote on any deviation from the agenda; the chair "shall intervene in proceedings to prevent any non-compliance"; and "should end or postpone the discussion or, if necessary, the entire meeting if compliance aspects need to be clarified." ## Contrast: committee chairing Article 18.4 uses a different model for Committees — each is "chaired by a member of the Board and co-chaired by an expert delegated from a distribution partner and appointed by the General Assembly," with exceptions for the Remuneration and Finance, Complaints and Supplier Committees. The Internal Regulations (`02firstboardmeeting__IATF_AISBL_-_05_Minutes_of_First_Board_Meeting_-_Annex_5_Internal_Regulations.txt`, ss. 12.3 and 13.4) add that those chairpersons and vice chairpersons "are appointed by the General Assembly for a renewable term of three years; the General Assembly may recall and/or replace the [chairperson]". None of this applies to the GA itself. ## What I searched and did not find I searched the corpus for *chair / preside / presiding*, *"President of the Board"*, *"chairs the meetings"* and the French *présider / Président du Conseil*. The only provisions on presiding over the General Assembly are Arts. 9.4 and 15.4(b) (with 15.1) of the Articles. **The Internal Regulations contain no separate rule on chairing the General Assembly** — their chairing provisions concern Committees only. Note also that the Minutes of the First General Assembly (`03firstgeneralassembly__IATF_AISBL_-_01_Minutes_of_First_General_Assembly.txt`) is a scanned image with no machine-readable text on any of its 12 pages, so I cannot tell you who in fact chaired that meeting, or whether the Board exercised the Art. 9.4 carve-out. That content is genuinely absent from the corpus. This is a summary of the documents, not legal advice.