Meeting Minutes Chat

articles of association - can a different committee overturn another committees decision

dgage@iaob.org · 2026-10-16 09:16 AM EDT

← Back
User 2026-10-16 09:17 AM EDT
articles of association - can a different committee overturn another committees decision
Assistant 2026-10-16 09:17 AM EDT
## Short answer No — nothing in the Articles of Association or the committee Internal Regulations gives one committee the power to overturn another committee's decision. Override powers exist, but they sit with the **General Assembly** and, to a limited extent, the **Board** — not with sibling committees. I searched the corpus for "overrule", "overturn", "override", "set aside", "reverse the decision", "annul", "revoke", "appeal" and "escalat" and found **no provision at all creating a hierarchy between committees**. ## What the governing text actually says **1. The Articles list the committees flat, with no ranking.** From `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Articles_of_Association_-_EN.txt`, Chapter V, Article 18.1: > "The Association shall at all times have the following committees whose functioning will be regulated by Internal Regulations: (a) Standardization Committee; (b) Global Oversight Committee ... (g) Complaints Committee ..." Articles 18.2–18.5 deal with establishing/abolishing committees, membership and chairing. None of them subordinates one committee to another. **2. Override sits with the General Assembly.** The clearest example is in the Internal Regulations (`02firstboardmeeting__IATF_AISBL_-_05_Minutes_of_First_Board_Meeting_-_Annex_5_Internal_Regulations.txt`), Section 12.8: > "The General Assembly may, by resolution in accordance with the Articles of Association, amend or rescind any remuneration policy adopted by the Remuneration and Finance Committee and any specific remuneration decisions by the Remuneration and Finance Committee." That power is expressly given to the General Assembly — and only in respect of the Remuneration and Finance Committee. There is no equivalent clause letting any committee do the same. **3. The only "parent/child" override is within a single committee's own structure.** Section 7.1 lets each Committee establish Working Groups, and Section 9.5.2(a) provides that where a Working Group cannot agree: > "the chairperson of the Working Group may request the Standardisation Committee as a whole to decide on such specific subject ... (i.e. the matter may ultimately be submitted to the General Assembly for decision if no consensus can be reached on the level of the Standardisation Committee)." So escalation runs *upward* — Working Group → parent Committee → General Assembly — never sideways to a different committee. **4. The Board coordinates but does not sit as an appeal body over committees.** Article 17.2(b) gives the Board power to "direct the work and coordinate the actions of all bodies with the Association", and Article 17.1 gives it "the broadest powers to implement the aims and activities of the Association as set by the General Assembly". Under Internal Regulations 5.1 the Board appoints and may "at any time recall and/or replace" committee chairpersons, and under 10.4 it may suspend an Oversight Office's participation rights for non-payment. These are control-of-process powers, not a power to reverse a committee resolution on its merits. **5. Some committee outputs never become final on their own anyway.** Standardisation Committee work requires General Assembly approval, not another committee's: Section 9.4 ("The initiation of a Standard Development is resolved by the General Assembly"), 9.5.2(f) (Draft Standard submitted to the General Assembly for approval) and 9.7 (SIs and FAQs "shall be approved by the General Assembly"). The Supplier Committee's route of influence over standards is by *input* — proposing a Standard Development under 9.3.1(f) and delegating two representatives into the Standardisation Committee under 11.4 and 9.1.2 — not by overturning anything. **6. Complaints Committee decisions are expressly immune from reversal.** Article 5.7 of the Articles: > "Any decisions by the Complaints Committee will be without appeal or other legal remedy." And Article 7 (exclusion of Members) similarly describes the Complaints Committee's decision as "without appeal or other legal remedy". ## Caveats — where the answer could change I should flag three gaps rather than resolve them: - **Section 3.2 of the Internal Regulations** allows the General Assembly to "issue a written mandate or terms of reference for all or specific Committees ... specifying the Committee's objectives, responsibilities, and reporting obligations." Any such mandate could in principle allocate decision rights differently. No such mandates appear in the corpus. - **One of the 15 pages of Annex 5 (the Internal Regulations) is a scanned image with no machine-readable text**, so its content is genuinely absent from the file I read. I cannot rule out that it bears on this. - The **Minutes of the First General Assembly** and the **Initial Committee Appointments** are scanned documents with no readable text on any page, so if committee decision rights were further specified there, I cannot see it. Also note Article 23.1: the Articles of Association "will at all times prevail over possible conflicting provisions of the Internal Regulations" — so if a tension ever arose between the two on this point, the Articles govern. This is a summary of what the documents say, not legal advice on how a particular inter-committee conflict should be resolved.
User 2026-10-16 09:34 AM EDT
is there a training committee or IT committee mentioned in the articles of association?
Assistant 2026-10-16 09:34 AM EDT
## Yes — both are mandatory committees under the Articles From `01foundingdeed__IATF_AISBL_-_Founding_Articles_of_Association_-_EN.txt`, Chapter V, **Article 18.1** (full list, no ellipsis this time): > "The Association shall at all times have the following committees whose functioning will be regulated by Internal Regulations: > (a) Standardization Committee; > (b) Global Oversight Committee, composed of representatives delegated by the oversight offices; > (c) Supplier Committee, composed of representatives of suppliers to be appointed as specified in the Internal Regulations; > (d) Remuneration and Finance Committee, composed of a minimum of three and a maximum of five Member representatives to be appointed by the General Assembly; > **(e) Training Committee;** > **(f) IT Committee; and** > (g) Complaints Committee ..." A correction to my previous answer: I abbreviated that list with an ellipsis, which obscured items (e) and (f). The Training Committee and IT Committee are expressly named in the Articles and are among the committees the Association must have "at all times". The same seven are repeated in the Founding Deed at the corresponding point. ## What the Articles say about them — and what they don't Notably, (e) and (f) are the **only two committees in Article 18.1 with no composition wording attached**. Every other entry specifies who sits on it; Training and IT are listed by name only. That means they fall to the **default** rules: - **Article 18.3** — "Each Member may appoint a representative, together with an alternate representative, to each Committee except for the Supplier Committee, the Complaints Committee and the Remuneration and Finance Committee." Training and IT are *not* in that carve-out, so the open-membership default applies, subject to the General Assembly's power in the same Article to limit numbers or require qualifications. - **Article 18.4** — "Each Committee will be chaired by a member of the Board and co-chaired by an expert delegated from a distribution partner and appointed by the General Assembly", with exceptions only for the Remuneration and Finance, Complaints and Supplier Committees. So Training and IT follow the Board-chair/distribution-partner-co-chair model. - **Article 23.2** — "The General Assembly will adopt Internal Regulations for each of the Committees." ## Gap worth flagging in the Internal Regulations In `02firstboardmeeting__IATF_AISBL_-_05_Minutes_of_First_Board_Meeting_-_Annex_5_Internal_Regulations.txt`, Section 2.1 lists the same seven committees, including "e) Training Committee; f) IT Committee". But **Part II (Special Provisions) has dedicated sections only for the Standardisation (9), Global Oversight (10), Supplier (11), Remuneration and Finance (12) and Complaints (13) Committees.** There is no Section for the Training Committee or the IT Committee. Section 4.3's list of deviations likewise omits them. So within the Internal Regulations as they stand, the Training and IT Committees are governed solely by the Part I general provisions (mandate, membership, chairperson, meetings and resolutions under Sections 3–8) with no special regime. I can't tell you from the corpus whether that is deliberate or a gap to be filled later — one of the 15 pages of Annex 5 is a scanned image with no machine-readable text, so I cannot rule out that something relevant sits there, and Section 3.2 allows the General Assembly to issue separate terms of reference for specific committees. ## Where the substance of these two committees does appear The detailed operating content for both is in the **Distribution Partner / Oversight Office contract**, not the Articles — `distributionpartnercontracts__260213_Distribution_Partner_Contract_for_the_Management_of_CBs_including_DP_and_CB_Eligibility_criteria_in_Annexes_CLEAN.txt` (draft of 13 February 2026), Section 10 (Training Committee) and Section 12 (IT Committee). For example: > "10.1 The Oversight Office shall participate in the Training Committee which is established, provided, and supervised by the IATF AISBL for the purpose of the development of 3rd Party Auditor Training (hereinafter: 'Training Development')." > "12.1 The Oversight Office shall participate **in an advisory capacity** in the IT Committee, which is established, provided, and supervised by the IATF AISBL for the purpose of overseeing and further developing the IATF AISBL's IT systems (hereinafter: 'IT Development')." The "advisory capacity" qualifier in 12.1 appears for the IT Committee but not the Training Committee. The same provisions appear in the pending-contracts annex to the first board meeting minutes. This is a summary of the documents, not legal advice.